Kotonoha no Niwa
Alternate Title: Garden of Words
[starrater]
Alternate Title: Garden of Words
[starrater]
Genshiken (Season 1)
Palm Studio
Dir. Takashi Ikehata (ep. dir. for Girls und Panzer, Strawberry Marshmallow, Inuyasha)
Wri. Michiko Yokote (5 ep. only) (Ah! My Goddess: The Movie, Rurouni Kenshin, Red Data Girl)
Mus. Masanori Takumi (Claymore, Koi Kaze, Witchblade)
SUMMARY
Genshiken follows the story of university freshman Kanji Sasahara. After perusing the various booths at the annual club rush, Sasahara settles on the club known as “gendai ni okeru shikaku wo chuushin to shita bunka no kenkyuu,” or rather “The Society for the Study of Modern Visual Culture.” This turns out to be an all encompassing otaku club, which is exactly what he wanted. Manga, anime, video games, cosplay, plastic models; you name it, Genshiken has its geeky toes dipped in it.
REVIEW
It’s not the prettiest thing to come out of the industry, but as a character piece, it doesn’t really need to be. The most visual impressive sequences are that of the imaginary-at-the-time anime “Kujibiki Unbalance,” which is a favorite among Genshiken’s members. The show has a nice visual style that isn’t too overblown. It really feels like it could make an easy and natural transition to the live-action medium.
For what one could certainly call an “otaku” show, the pandering and fan service is almost non-existent. The largely episodic stories feel all at once like an introspective on otaku culture and a celebration of what sets it apart and brings its participants together. In as much as the the Jackass franchise isn’t really about pranks and stunts but rather about camaraderie and friendship, so is Genshiken. To examine what brings people together is to examine people themselves, and Genshiken does this quite lovingly.
Like I mentioned before, the show is very episodic. Relationships progress serially, but events are mostly unconnected episode-to-episode. This works well for the different corners of fandom that the show attempts to tackle with each installment, but does little to encourage the viewer to watch more. I often felt satisfied watching a single episode and doing something else for awhile. It’s very pleasant viewing experience, but not terribly engaging.
The music is cute and never inappropriate, but doesn’t set itself apart in any particular way. The opening theme, however, has become one of my favorite anime openings of all time.
At the core of this show’s success are its characters. Truly loving portraits of believable archetypes among otaku – not terribly flattering, but never mean-spirited. Just honest, perhaps. Among the characters is a woman unlike any I had seen in anime prior to watching Genshiken, nor have I seen since. Her name is Saki Kasukabe (played with deft cynicism by Satsuki Yukino). She’s a smoking, drinking, fiercely independent upperclassman who starts dating Genshiken’s resident pretty-boy game wizard Makoto Kousaka, a choice she has no qualms about admitting were for his looks alone. She has no interest in anything otaku related and struggles for much of the series trying to understand why this hobby is so important to her boyfriend and his club mates. It’s a relationship that never feels forced or unearned, but rather real and unflinching; two people sitting in a room discussing whether they’re going to have sex later – one of them playing a video game, the other smoking a cigarette. If anything negative could be said about their relationship, its that Kousaka never does much of anything but play games, while Kasukabe is constantly trying to figure him and this whole “otaku” thing out. Kasukabe eventually comes around, but she’s never meant to be the syphon for a quote-unquote “normal” audience. A series like The Big Bang Theory never seems to be on the side of the outcasts. For a show that’s told from the perspective of geeks, the brunt of its humor is at the expense of those giving us perspective. The “normies” in the show provide the audience with a relatable escape from all the sci-fi references and indignant, glasses-pushing, academic one-upsmanship. Genshiken deserves huge points for making Kasukabe exactly what she is to the rest of the characters: an outsider.
All things considered, Genshiken is something special that we doesn’t get enough of these days. It’s a nice, well-meaning, thematically consistent piece about camaraderie on the outskirts of pop culture. Recommended to anyone who has ever called themselves a geek or any variation thereof.
4 glasses pushes out of 5.
[starrater]
Score for the overall series ended up at a 4, but the third season sits at a 5.
[starrater]
[starrater]
Alternate Titles:
Oreimo
[starrater]
Mangirl!
Studio: Dogakobo
Dir. Nobuaki Nakanishi
Wri. Masahiro Yokotani & Reiko Yoshida
SYNOPSIS
A team of girls with zero experience in manga editing are off and running toward their dream of creating the biggest manga magazine in Japan! They seem to do nothing but run into problems and failures… But still they’re working hard every day!
REVIEW
+ Characters are cute and well differentiated visually.
+ The show has a very colorful, glossy look to it. Everything kind of looks like candy, especially the characters’ hair.
+/- Music is unremarkable. At least it’s not inappropriate and distracting. Theme song is cute, but a little irritating and manic.
– Very clearly made on the cheap. Not a big need for action, so nothing to complain about there. Lots and lots of static frames.
– The central conflict of the show is simply running this magazine. Each episode has it’s own conflict that emerges and gets resolved within the three-minute runtime. Because of this conflicts are resolved almost as soon they arise, often with nothing more than a jump cut and a line of dialogue like: “Somehow we overcame this obstacle! Yay!” It really feels like this show wants to be a full-length half-hour program, but simply doesn’t have the time to explore its episodic conflicts in an interesting way.
– Aside from the two most prominent characters, performances aren’t all that varied or unique. Everyone has the same cute cadence to their voice, which doesn’t lend much to their characters. The show has barely enough time to showcase the individual characters’ idiosyncrasies, so you end up with impressions like “the crazy one,” “the serious one,” “the kinda dumb one,” and “the one who likes donuts.”
Overall it’s a pretty cute, mildly interesting (albeit probably inaccurate look) at the manga publishing world.
[starrater]
2.5 donuts out of five.
Alternate Titles: Ookami kodomo no Ame to Yuki
Run Time: 117 minutes
Release Date: 5 June 2012
Tech:
Studio Chizu/Madhouse
Ookami Kodomo no Ame to Yuki
Dir. Mamoru Hosoda
Wri. Mamoru Hosoda, Satoko Okudera
Music by Takagi Masakatsu
Pros:
– Animation is stunning. An impressive first outing for Studio Chizu.
– The drama is genuine and touching. A really great story about raising children as a single mother.
– Never allows its premise to hijack the narrative. While the threat of the children being discovered is always present, it never reduces the movie to that central conflict.
– Music is gorgeous and subtle. It creates an effective emotional canvas for the story events to be painted upon.
Cons:
– A little bit of furry fan service early on is really distracting
– The voice actors for 10 and 13 year old Ame and Yuki are cast WAY too old
– Yuki’s voice over narration is wholly unnecessary and needlessly expository
[starrater]
Alternate Titles: Kokuriko Zaka Kara
Kokuriko Zaka Kara
Studio Ghibli
Dir. Goro Miyazaki
Wri. Hayao Miyazaki, Keiko Niwa
Music Satoshi Takebe
Synopsis:
Umi Matsuzaki is a high school girl living in the Coquelicot Manor, a boarding house in Japan in the 1960s. She meets Shun Kazama and they decide to clean up the school’s clubhouse: Quartier Latin. But, a local businessman and chairman of the local high school Tokumaru decides to demolish the building and Umi and Shun launch into an effort to get him to reconsider.
Pros:
– Animation is beautiful. The interiors feel truly lived in. The kitchen of Coquelicot Manor and the Latin Quarter clubhouse are especially impressive. The exteriors are lush and warm. Very precise and detailed. Par for the course for Ghibli.
– Performances are subtle and nuanced. Actors give emotional resonance to their animated avatars.
– Music is mostly beautiful appropriate, but Joe Hisaishi is missed.
– Story is cute, if a little slight and predictable.
Cons:
– Nothing we haven’t seen before, story-wise. One plot point in particular feels a little too soap-opera-y.
– There are a few strange music choices that don’t feel emotionally compatible to the scenario.
– Feels a little too sentimental and
nostalgic. Like Makoto Shinkai by way of Hayao Miyazaki, two great tastes that don’t taste terribly good together.
– It’s biggest crime is that it’s kind of boring. It has the slice-of-life quality that Isao Takahata’s films typically bring to Studio Ghibli’s body of work, but isn’t nearly as entertaining as a Takahata film.
Rating: 3 signal flags out of 5.
[starrater]
[starrater]
Alternative Title:
Sound of the Sky
[starrater]